July 28, 2005 - A tale of sadness & survival12A • The Suffolk Times • July 28, 2005
Suffolk Times photo by Paul Sloutwburgh
As long as there Is a plentiful supply of food there Is peace In the osprey nest (left), but should there be a shortage, then the strongest one takes over and the
weaker one loses out. This action by the young Is not unusual in the hawk family. Right: A male harbor seal pup recovered from Smith Point County Park with
its umbilical cord still attached. This recovery and another one farther west are the first confirmed documentations of 'pupping' on Long Island.
A tale of sadness &survival
IF You cAN r srANn a little sadness,
then this is not for you. All is not the
way we would like to have it in the nat-
ural world. Just recently a good friend
of mine called and said one of his
young ospreys was on the ground. He
and his wife had watched this family
of ospreys through a scope
in an upstairs window from
the day they Cost arrived
in March. I'm sure many O N
of you have done the same
thing in one way or another.
Up to a day ago, it had
been a delightful pastime to
peak into the private fives of
this osprey fancily and watch
the young grow. Then the unexpected
happened. One of the two young was
seen on the ground below the nest, and
here is where I came in.
My friend called to tell of the disaster
and asked if I could give him some ad-
vice on what to do. We've put young os-
preys back in their nests when they've
been found tangled in monofilament
fish line or found out of the nest for
some other reason. I explained it was
really quite simple, but now my wife
says no more climbing ladders — leave
it to the younger ones to do the climb-
ing — and so I went on to tell him to
cover the bird in a towel or something
so it would stay calm as the climber
went up to the nest and then just put
the bird back in. Now all my friend had
to do was find someone with a sturdy
extension ladder and a will to climb.
Within a few hours I received a call
from Richard to say they had followed
my suggestions and had successfully
put the young osprey back in the nest,
but in so doing had scared the other
young osprey, which flew
away to a nearby tree. Ev-
erything looked like luck had
been on the young osprey's
side; soon it looked like
things would go back to nor-
mal. Not so, and here comes
the hard part to understand.
It is not that unusual in the
family of hawks for a larger
and stronger young to become very
aggressive and often viciously attack
the weaker one, which this one began
to do once he flew back to the nest. The
parents flew in and just sat nearby and
watched big brother or sister literally
peck away at the weakened young os-
prey until it killed it. At no time did the
parents stop, or even make any attempt
to stop, the harassment.
This is hard for us humans to un-
derstand. Could it be that the parents
found fish scarce and there wasn't
enough food for both young, and the
older, stronger sibling solved the prob-
lem by pushing the weaker one out
of the nest? This might have been the
reason in the beginning that the weaker
osprey was found on the ground be-
FOCUS
NATURE
by Paul
Stoutenburgh
PEI A 4111,
- 1111111i
y�
III R' • Moss Rock
f� I ' • Pnrkgstanos
• •
R&.MdM Wall
Sysloms
Family Owsed A Oprabd Since 1397 cam nt. Mo a
a woe
3t cnikrad Smna
? • ma,
• Connele Block,
low the nest. Remember, there was no
attempt by either parent to stop the
stronger one's actiorts'Ihe weaker os-
prey couldn't fly to get away so it had
to suffer the consequences. Perhaps the
bigger osprey had hatched first, mak-
ing it stronger and more aggressive and
thus able to take more of the food, and
the one that didn't live had just never
been able to keep up.
Once again, I have to repeat that this
action is quite normal in the hawk fam-
ily. It helps guarantee that at least one
strong, healthy hawk will survive. In o
world, we would have tried to help the
weaker one, but not so in the natural
world, where survival is all that counts
Sentiments play no part in the hard -to-
realize world where only the strong and
the healthy survive.
It's like so many telephone calls I
get from very concerned and thought-
ful people who ask what to do with a
baby bird that's lost its mother, etc. I
tell them to leave it alone
and the mother will find Senti
it, and if she doesn't, that's
nature's way of weeding play n
out the weak, the slow, the In the
unqualified. It sounds cruel
to us, but it's been working
since time began.
The next heartbreak is
about a baby seal. I got a
call from Linda that there
was a baby seal on the beach and
would I like to see it. Well, that surely
was something we would like to see, for
baby seals are not usually born this far
south. Their nursery and home is far-
ther north along the rocky coast where
the water is colder and the environ-
ment provides better protection than
our hot, sandy beaches.
In no time Barbara and I were off
to the appointed location, which was
on the beach west of New Suffolk.This
was going to be a first for us, for the
only seals we had ever seen this far up
in the bay were spotted during the win-
ter, when they would be seen on a rock
off New Suffolk proper.
When we got to the location, Bar-
bara
met some friends who told us it
was farther up the beach, so I drove
with one of the men to the spot farther
to the west while Barbara walked the
beach with her friends When we got
there, sorrow filled the air. A small
group of people huddled over a dead
baby seal that still had its placenta
loosely wrapped around it. We felt
awful to see this dead pup in front of
us. As we all looked on in sadness, the
waves gently rocked the little body
back and forth, almost as if it were
trying to revive it. But then there I go,
trying to attach human feelings to the
animal world. They don't belong there,
I know, but it's hard to separate our
feelings
Barbara had her cell phone and for
our
20 minutes tried to reach the research
team at Atlantis in Riverhead, where
we knew the people would be inter-
ested in picking up this baby seal for
smdy.'Ihey are interested in live or
dead seals in our area, as they all, alive
or dead, give researchers data to build
their studies on. None of our telephone
numbers worked, so we did the next
best thing — we took the seal to Riv-
erhead.They were apologetic about
their tedious telephone
ments answering system but glad
to have the seal to exam-
part me. We found out that the
world best thing to do if you find
a seal or turtle anywhere
along our beaches is to
can their hotline at (631)
369 -9829. They are profes-
sionals and know how to
handle such situations
They told us they had recovered two
live seal pups born this season on Long
Island. These recoveries are the first
confirmed documentation of "pup-
ping" on the island; one was found at
Smith Point County Park on the south
shore and the other one was farther
west. Both pups are both doing well at
the center. The first pup was recovered
on May 28 with the umbilical cord still
attached. They figured it was just seven
days old. All at the research complex in
Riverhead are looking forward to soon
releasing the pups back into their natu-
ral environment.
Kimberly Durham, the Rescue
Program director in Riverhead, said
we could see a video of the first pup if
we logged onto their website at www.
riverheadfoundation.org. Hopefully
the video of this live pup will make us
all feel better after having read about
some of the heartbreak we experi-
enced this week.
where only the
strong and the
healthy survive.
• Bann. Wal?M ne
to "-I
• Nfia Blocks
• coeda,tona
• Bluestone
ur •rom...'
.sononmes
ambrldge
Bea -Mix
iG 7 Pavmgstonca
• Taa,au a Much
x+milr�,l V� ➢�`UIYA.-
•11 -Rock
•Gmoml shale
• cimcc.y add.,
www. cambrid a aver;.coin
`-1,1 c-11
9 P
used a aks IIo
• Sand and so muat
low the nest. Remember, there was no
attempt by either parent to stop the
stronger one's actiorts'Ihe weaker os-
prey couldn't fly to get away so it had
to suffer the consequences. Perhaps the
bigger osprey had hatched first, mak-
ing it stronger and more aggressive and
thus able to take more of the food, and
the one that didn't live had just never
been able to keep up.
Once again, I have to repeat that this
action is quite normal in the hawk fam-
ily. It helps guarantee that at least one
strong, healthy hawk will survive. In o
world, we would have tried to help the
weaker one, but not so in the natural
world, where survival is all that counts
Sentiments play no part in the hard -to-
realize world where only the strong and
the healthy survive.
It's like so many telephone calls I
get from very concerned and thought-
ful people who ask what to do with a
baby bird that's lost its mother, etc. I
tell them to leave it alone
and the mother will find Senti
it, and if she doesn't, that's
nature's way of weeding play n
out the weak, the slow, the In the
unqualified. It sounds cruel
to us, but it's been working
since time began.
The next heartbreak is
about a baby seal. I got a
call from Linda that there
was a baby seal on the beach and
would I like to see it. Well, that surely
was something we would like to see, for
baby seals are not usually born this far
south. Their nursery and home is far-
ther north along the rocky coast where
the water is colder and the environ-
ment provides better protection than
our hot, sandy beaches.
In no time Barbara and I were off
to the appointed location, which was
on the beach west of New Suffolk.This
was going to be a first for us, for the
only seals we had ever seen this far up
in the bay were spotted during the win-
ter, when they would be seen on a rock
off New Suffolk proper.
When we got to the location, Bar-
bara
met some friends who told us it
was farther up the beach, so I drove
with one of the men to the spot farther
to the west while Barbara walked the
beach with her friends When we got
there, sorrow filled the air. A small
group of people huddled over a dead
baby seal that still had its placenta
loosely wrapped around it. We felt
awful to see this dead pup in front of
us. As we all looked on in sadness, the
waves gently rocked the little body
back and forth, almost as if it were
trying to revive it. But then there I go,
trying to attach human feelings to the
animal world. They don't belong there,
I know, but it's hard to separate our
feelings
Barbara had her cell phone and for
our
20 minutes tried to reach the research
team at Atlantis in Riverhead, where
we knew the people would be inter-
ested in picking up this baby seal for
smdy.'Ihey are interested in live or
dead seals in our area, as they all, alive
or dead, give researchers data to build
their studies on. None of our telephone
numbers worked, so we did the next
best thing — we took the seal to Riv-
erhead.They were apologetic about
their tedious telephone
ments answering system but glad
to have the seal to exam-
part me. We found out that the
world best thing to do if you find
a seal or turtle anywhere
along our beaches is to
can their hotline at (631)
369 -9829. They are profes-
sionals and know how to
handle such situations
They told us they had recovered two
live seal pups born this season on Long
Island. These recoveries are the first
confirmed documentation of "pup-
ping" on the island; one was found at
Smith Point County Park on the south
shore and the other one was farther
west. Both pups are both doing well at
the center. The first pup was recovered
on May 28 with the umbilical cord still
attached. They figured it was just seven
days old. All at the research complex in
Riverhead are looking forward to soon
releasing the pups back into their natu-
ral environment.
Kimberly Durham, the Rescue
Program director in Riverhead, said
we could see a video of the first pup if
we logged onto their website at www.
riverheadfoundation.org. Hopefully
the video of this live pup will make us
all feel better after having read about
some of the heartbreak we experi-
enced this week.
where only the
strong and the
healthy survive.