March 16, 2000 - The osprey's ongoing saga8A • The Suffolk Times • March 16, 2000
The osprey's ongoing saga
How reassuring it was to see the
first osprey last week. And to think it
came to the highest point in Southold
Town, the high tower behind the high-
way department in Peconic. From
there it can survey the land for miles
around and it is but a short flight to
the fishing grounds of our creeks and
bays, where it will dive and retrieve its
food.
It's believed
that ospreys
mate for life and
meet each year
back at their old
nest. All winter
long they have
been by them-
selves fishing in the Caribbean or as
far south as the Amazon River in
Brazil. This particular osprey that is
building its nest on the high tower is
all by itself and I'm not sure whether
it is the male or female. Either way, it
isn't wasting any time, for I saw it fly
in with a stick or branch to add to the
nest. This adding to the nest each year
in some instances can be a real prob-
lem, particularly when the nest is in an
old tree. Each year new material is
added and the nest gets bigger and
bigger until the sheer weight of it
breaks the limb and the nest comes
tumbling down. This isn't a problem if
it happens during the off season but
when it happens during nesting time,
whole clutches can be lost.
The actual sighting of an osprey in
the early part of March tells us there
are other changes taking place in our
world. It tells us that the water has
warmed up and that there is a new
awakening in the mud. The eels and
flounders that the osprey lives on dur-
ing these early months are vital for
their survival. Later, as the menhaden,
or bunkers, move in, along with the
weakfish, stripers and others, they will
become fair game. The bunker, in par-
ticular, is one of the favorite foods of
the osprey and the one most often
caught. Schools of these bunkers were
once common throughout our bays
and Sound but lately their numbers
have dwindled because of overfishing.
And now a new threat is taking its
toll. Some people feel this new threat
is depleting the bunker schools and
therefore making it difficult for the
ospreys to find enough food to feed
their young.
As I said earlier bunkers were the
mainstay of the osprey. Often, if you
Focus
ON
NATURE
by Paul
Stoutenburgh
look closely, you can see the shiny
menhaden in the claws of the osprey
as it flies by. When we spent summers
on the beach the osprey from the
nearby nest would often fly low
directly over us carrying these shining
fish. The predator that has moved in
to cut down the number of bunkers
available is the cormorant. This skillful
fisherman has literally increased by
the thousands in our local waters and
one of its prime foods
is the menhaden, par-
ticularly the young
menhaden.
Dr. Paul Spitzer,
who worked many
years ago with our
local ospreys, believes
cormorants might be
one of the reasons we
had such poor nesting
results in our osprey
population Last year.
Could this lack of
menhaden be the
cause? At one time
this fish was so com-
mon that they were
caught in long nets
from shore by the mil-
lions and used as fer-
tilizer on our farms.
Needless to say, you
could tell when there
were good hauls
because there was an
odor in the air of rot-
ting fish. The Indians
had taught the white
man to put a fish
under every hill of corn. Later fish
meal from fish such as the bunker was
made into fertilizer and even food
supplements for cattle and poultry.
The depletion of the bunkers shows
once again man's greed. He literally
fished himself out of the menhaden
business and in so doing changed
nature's balance.
The increase in the cormorant pop-
ulation has become such a problem
that in places where commercial fish-
ing is taking place harsh steps are
being called for. The destruction of the
eggs at the nesting sites is being con-
sidered. Nature has become out of
balance and solutions are not that eas-
ily found.
I have worked with ospreys for the
past 40 or 50 years and have seen
many of their nests. Some, like on
Gardiners Island, are built right on
the sand because they have no land
predators. Through the years their
nests have piled up rubble three to six
feet in height. I've seen an osprey fly
toward a tree, grab onto a branch and
snap it off and carry it back to its
nest. When cornstalks were the thing
years ago I remember seeing an
osprey dive down to the ground and
pick up a cornstalk and fly back to its
nest.
rassed by them. The gulls are so per-
sistent that the osprey spends much of
its time defending its nesting site
when it should be out fishing. A par-
tial solution was to move platforms
inland on the island to get the ospreys
away from the gulls. Once again we
see nature out of balance, perhaps
because man has provided so much
food for the gulls and made their pick-
ings so rewarding.
Robins Island, on the other hand,
still does not have gulls nesting on its
shores. It's the outer islands like Plum
and Gardiners that they nest on. The
Paul Spitzer banding a young osprey
back In 1973. The banded birds tell us
where they migrate, how old they grow
and much about their nesting habits.
This picture shows a typical nest on
the beach at Gardln..is Island.
pLANN1Nc
ANb OCS1E N
On -site design studio including
a library of fabrics and wallpapers.
Serving the North Fork
for over six years.
Access to New York "trade only'
design showrooms.
Offering a wide variety of services,
including in -home consultations.
CDRy Casey lnteRloRs
28320 Main Road, Cutchogue ■ 734 -2532
All sorts of objects are used — old
shoes, rope, seaweed, plastics, almost
anything — and even the deadly
killer, monofilament fishing line,
finds its way into the nesting site.
I've rescued, with the help of my son,
two ospreys that were dangling
underneath their nests after they had
been entangled in monofilament fish
line. The fisherman who takes the
line off the reel and throws it over-
board is doing a grave injustice
somewhere down the line (no pun
intended). Monofilament never rots
or decays but lays a deadly trap for
fish, crabs, osprey and other birds.
Some will get entangled and starve
to a horrible death just because they
can't rid themselves of someone's
careless act.
The natural location for an osprey
nest is in a tree and when I was a kid
that was the only place you'd find
them. Later as I grew up I'd find they
nested directly on the beach at Gar -
diners Island but there they have had
problems with gulls. The herring gull
and the black- backed gull have be-
come so numerous on the island that
the osprey is continually being ha-
Be a master birder
Cornell Cooperative Extension
marine program offers a seasonal
master birder program in four ses-
sions, April 1, 16 and May 12 ' 13 *
The course consists of slide lec-
tures, labs, avian anatomy, physiol-
ogy, behavior, conservation and
seasonal field trips to observe
birds. Cost: per session $150, four
sessions $500.
Call 852-8660.
Suffolk Times photo by Paul Stoutenburgh
ospreys on Robins Island still build
their nests in trees in the conventional
way. If you want to see ospreys in
their native habitat, which is rather
hard to find these days, Robins Island
is the place. Not that you can go on
the island, but you can sail around it
and see from the water the magnifi-
cent tree nests along its edge.
While we are on the topic of os-
preys, Barbara and I have spent a
good deal of time riding around to see
if we could find the first osprey to
arrive. One of the last places we vis-
ited was Orient Beach State Park and
what do you think we found? Atop
one of the platforms, a mere 300 feet
west of the buildings, out in the marsh
to the right, was a great horned owl
nesting on an osprey platform. We vis-
ited it twice and each time we could
plainly see the fluffy tufts of feathers
that look like ears on this magnificent
predator. So get in Y our car and take a
trip to the state park. It's always a
rewarding experience.
NFEC gathering set
Members of the North Fork En-
vironmental Council can get ac-
quainted, or reacquainted, at a mem-
bers' night planned for Saturday,
March 25, at Laurel Lake Vineyards.
A joint coalition - building meeting
for East End and Riverhead members
begins at 6 p.m., followed by a chili
and cornbread dinner at 7.
Other upcoming NFEC events
include a Go Organic 2000 Fair at
Suffolk County Community College
on April 1; spring organic workshops;
the annual golf outing at Island's End
on May 15; and the annual Summer
Gala on Jul 8.
Call 298 -8880.
SA • The Suffolk Times • March 16, 2000
The ospre
s ongoing saga
How reassuring it was to see the
first osprey last week. And to think it
came to the highest point in Southold
Town, the high tower behind the high-
way department in Peconic. From
there it can survey the land for miles
around and it is but a short flight to
the fishing grounds of our creeks and
bays, where it will dive and retrieve its
food.
It's believed Focus
that ospreys
mate for life and ON
meet each year NATURE
back at their old
nest. All winter by Raul
long they have Stoutenburgh
been by them-
Suffolk Times photo by Paul Stoutenburgh
selves fishing in the Caribbean or as
far south as the Amazon River in
Brazil. This particular osprey that is
building its nest on the high tower is
all by itself and I'm not sure whether
it is the male or female. Either way, it
isn't wasting any time, for I saw it fly
in with a stick or branch to add to the
nest. This adding to the nest each year
in some instances can be a real prob-
lem, particularly when the nest is in an
old tree. Each year new material is
added and the nest gets bigger and
bigger until the sheer weight of it
breaks the limb and the nest comes
tumbling down. This isn't a problem if
it happens during the off season but
when it happens during nesting time,
The actual sighting of an osprey in
the early part of March tells us there
are other changes taking place in our
world. It tells us that the water has
warml�,d,up and that there is a new
awakening in the mud. The eels and
flounders that the osprey lives on dur-
ing these early months are vital for
their survival. Later, as the menhaden,
or bunkers, move in, along with the
weakfish, stripers and others, they will
become fair game. The bunker, in par-
ticular, is one of the favorite foods of
the osprey and the one most often
caught. Schools of these bunkers were
once common throughout our bays
and Sound but lately their numbers
have dwindled because of overfishing.
And now a new threat is taking its
toll. Some people feel this new threat
is depleting the bunker schools and
therefore making it difficult for the
ospreys to find enough food to feed
their young.
As I said earlier bunkers were the
mainstay of the osprey. Often, if you
look closely, you can see the shiny
menhaden in the claws of the osprey
as it flies by. When we spent summers
on the beach the osprey from the
nearby nest would often fly low
directly over us carrying these shining
fish. The predator that has moved in
to cut down the number of bunkers
available is the cormorant. This skillful
fisherman has literally increased by
the thousands in our local waters and
one of its prime foods
is the menhaden, par-
ticularly the young
menhaden.
Dr. Paul Spitzer,
who worked many
years ago with our
local ospreys, believes
cormorants might be
one of the reasons we
had such poor nesting
results in our osprey
population last year.
Could this lack of
menhaden be the
cause? At one time
this fish was so com-
mon that they were
caught in long nets
from shore by the mil-
lions and used as fer-
tilizer on our farms.
Needless to say, you
could tell when there
were good hauls
because there was an
odor in the air of rot-
ting fish. The Indians
had taught the white
under every hill of corn. Later fish
meal from fish such as the bunker was
made into fertilizer and even food
upplements for cattle and poultry.
e depletion of the bunkers shows
nce again man's greed. He literally
ished himself out of the menhaden
usiness and in so doing changed
nature's balance.
The increase in the cormorant pop-
ulation has become such a problem
that in places where commercial fish-
ing is taking place harsh steps are
being called for. The destruction of the
eggs at the nesting sites is being con-
sidered. Nature has become out of
balance and solutions are not that eas-
ily found.
I have worked with ospreys for the
past 40 or 50 years and have seen
many of their nests. Some, like on
Gardiners Island, are built right on
the sand because they have no land
predators. Through the years their
nests have piled up rubble three to six
feet in height. I've seen an osprey fly
toward a tree, grab onto a branch and
snap it off and carry it back to its
nest. When cornstalks were the thing
years ago I remember seeing an
osprey dive down to the ground and
pick up a cornstalk and fly back to its
All sorts of objects are used — old
shoes, rope, seaweed, plastics, almost
anything — and even the deadly
killer, monofilament fishing line,
finds its way into the nesting site.
I've rescued, with the help of my son,
two ospreys that were dangling
underneath their nests after they had
been entangled in monofilament fish
line. The fisherman who takes the
line off the reel and throws it over-
board is doing a grave injustice
somewhere down the line (no pun
intended). Monofilament never rots
or decays but lays a deadly trap for
fish, crabs, osprey and other birds.
Some will get entangled and starve
to a horrible death just because they
can't rid themselves of someone's
careless act.
The natural location for an osprey
nest is in a tree and when I was a kid
that was the only place you'd find
them. Later as I grew up I'd find they
nested directly on the beach at Gar -
diners Island but there they have had
problems with gulls. The herring gull
and the black- backed gull have be-
come so numerous on the island that
the osprey is continually being ha-
w== --- mw�
'assed by them. The gulls are so per-
sistent that the osprey spends much of
its time defending its nesting site
when it should be out fishing. A par-
tial solution was to move platforms
inland on the island to get the ospreys
away from the gulls. Once again we
see nature out of balance, perhaps
because man has provided so much
food for the gulls and made their pick-
ings so rewarding.
Robins Island, on the other hand,
still does not have gulls nesting on its
shores. It's the outer islands like Plum
and Gardiners that they nest on. The
ospreys on Robins Island still build
their nests in trees in the conventional
way. If you want to see ospreys in
their native habitat, which is rather
hard to find these days, Robins Island
is the place. Not that you can go on
the island, but you can sail around it
and see from the water the magnifi-
cent tree nests along its edge.
While we are on the topic of os-
preys, Barbara and I have spent a
good deal of time riding around to see
if we could find the first osprey to
arrive. One of the last places we vis-
ited was Orient Beach State Park and
what do you think we found? Atop
one of the platforms, a mere 300 feet
west of the buildings, out in the marsh
to the right, was a great horned owl
nesting on an osprey platform. We vis-
ited it twice and each time we could
plainly see the fluffy tufts of feathers
that look like ears on this magnificent
predator. So get in your car and take a
trip to the state park. It's always a
SA • The Suffolk Times • March 16, 2000
The ospre
s ongoing saga
How reassuring it was to see the
first osprey last week. And to think it
came to the highest point in Southold
Town, the high tower behind the high-
way department in Peconic. From
there it can survey the land for miles
around and it is but a short flight to
the fishing grounds of our creeks and
bays, where it will dive and retrieve its
food.
It's believed Focus
that ospreys
mate for life and ON
meet each year NATURE
back at their old
nest. All winter by Raul
long they have Stoutenburgh
been by them-
Suffolk Times photo by Paul Stoutenburgh
selves fishing in the Caribbean or as
far south as the Amazon River in
Brazil. This particular osprey that is
building its nest on the high tower is
all by itself and I'm not sure whether
it is the male or female. Either way, it
isn't wasting any time, for I saw it fly
in with a stick or branch to add to the
nest. This adding to the nest each year
in some instances can be a real prob-
lem, particularly when the nest is in an
old tree. Each year new material is
added and the nest gets bigger and
bigger until the sheer weight of it
breaks the limb and the nest comes
tumbling down. This isn't a problem if
it happens during the off season but
when it happens during nesting time,
The actual sighting of an osprey in
the early part of March tells us there
are other changes taking place in our
world. It tells us that the water has
warml�,d,up and that there is a new
awakening in the mud. The eels and
flounders that the osprey lives on dur-
ing these early months are vital for
their survival. Later, as the menhaden,
or bunkers, move in, along with the
weakfish, stripers and others, they will
become fair game. The bunker, in par-
ticular, is one of the favorite foods of
the osprey and the one most often
caught. Schools of these bunkers were
once common throughout our bays
and Sound but lately their numbers
have dwindled because of overfishing.
And now a new threat is taking its
toll. Some people feel this new threat
is depleting the bunker schools and
therefore making it difficult for the
ospreys to find enough food to feed
their young.
As I said earlier bunkers were the
mainstay of the osprey. Often, if you
look closely, you can see the shiny
menhaden in the claws of the osprey
as it flies by. When we spent summers
on the beach the osprey from the
nearby nest would often fly low
directly over us carrying these shining
fish. The predator that has moved in
to cut down the number of bunkers
available is the cormorant. This skillful
fisherman has literally increased by
the thousands in our local waters and
one of its prime foods
is the menhaden, par-
ticularly the young
menhaden.
Dr. Paul Spitzer,
who worked many
years ago with our
local ospreys, believes
cormorants might be
one of the reasons we
had such poor nesting
results in our osprey
population last year.
Could this lack of
menhaden be the
cause? At one time
this fish was so com-
mon that they were
caught in long nets
from shore by the mil-
lions and used as fer-
tilizer on our farms.
Needless to say, you
could tell when there
were good hauls
because there was an
odor in the air of rot-
ting fish. The Indians
had taught the white
under every hill of corn. Later fish
meal from fish such as the bunker was
made into fertilizer and even food
upplements for cattle and poultry.
e depletion of the bunkers shows
nce again man's greed. He literally
ished himself out of the menhaden
usiness and in so doing changed
nature's balance.
The increase in the cormorant pop-
ulation has become such a problem
that in places where commercial fish-
ing is taking place harsh steps are
being called for. The destruction of the
eggs at the nesting sites is being con-
sidered. Nature has become out of
balance and solutions are not that eas-
ily found.
I have worked with ospreys for the
past 40 or 50 years and have seen
many of their nests. Some, like on
Gardiners Island, are built right on
the sand because they have no land
predators. Through the years their
nests have piled up rubble three to six
feet in height. I've seen an osprey fly
toward a tree, grab onto a branch and
snap it off and carry it back to its
nest. When cornstalks were the thing
years ago I remember seeing an
osprey dive down to the ground and
pick up a cornstalk and fly back to its
All sorts of objects are used — old
shoes, rope, seaweed, plastics, almost
anything — and even the deadly
killer, monofilament fishing line,
finds its way into the nesting site.
I've rescued, with the help of my son,
two ospreys that were dangling
underneath their nests after they had
been entangled in monofilament fish
line. The fisherman who takes the
line off the reel and throws it over-
board is doing a grave injustice
somewhere down the line (no pun
intended). Monofilament never rots
or decays but lays a deadly trap for
fish, crabs, osprey and other birds.
Some will get entangled and starve
to a horrible death just because they
can't rid themselves of someone's
careless act.
The natural location for an osprey
nest is in a tree and when I was a kid
that was the only place you'd find
them. Later as I grew up I'd find they
nested directly on the beach at Gar -
diners Island but there they have had
problems with gulls. The herring gull
and the black- backed gull have be-
come so numerous on the island that
the osprey is continually being ha-
w== --- mw�
'assed by them. The gulls are so per-
sistent that the osprey spends much of
its time defending its nesting site
when it should be out fishing. A par-
tial solution was to move platforms
inland on the island to get the ospreys
away from the gulls. Once again we
see nature out of balance, perhaps
because man has provided so much
food for the gulls and made their pick-
ings so rewarding.
Robins Island, on the other hand,
still does not have gulls nesting on its
shores. It's the outer islands like Plum
and Gardiners that they nest on. The
ospreys on Robins Island still build
their nests in trees in the conventional
way. If you want to see ospreys in
their native habitat, which is rather
hard to find these days, Robins Island
is the place. Not that you can go on
the island, but you can sail around it
and see from the water the magnifi-
cent tree nests along its edge.
While we are on the topic of os-
preys, Barbara and I have spent a
good deal of time riding around to see
if we could find the first osprey to
arrive. One of the last places we vis-
ited was Orient Beach State Park and
what do you think we found? Atop
one of the platforms, a mere 300 feet
west of the buildings, out in the marsh
to the right, was a great horned owl
nesting on an osprey platform. We vis-
ited it twice and each time we could
plainly see the fluffy tufts of feathers
that look like ears on this magnificent
predator. So get in your car and take a
trip to the state park. It's always a
SA • The Suffolk Times • March 16, 2000
The ospre
s ongoing saga
How reassuring it was to see the
first osprey last week. And to think it
came to the highest point in Southold
Town, the high tower behind the high-
way department in Peconic. From
there it can survey the land for miles
around and it is but a short flight to
the fishing grounds of our creeks and
bays, where it will dive and retrieve its
food.
It's believed Focus
that ospreys
mate for life and ON
meet each year NATURE
back at their old
nest. All winter by Raul
long they have Stoutenburgh
been by them-
Suffolk Times photo by Paul Stoutenburgh
selves fishing in the Caribbean or as
far south as the Amazon River in
Brazil. This particular osprey that is
building its nest on the high tower is
all by itself and I'm not sure whether
it is the male or female. Either way, it
isn't wasting any time, for I saw it fly
in with a stick or branch to add to the
nest. This adding to the nest each year
in some instances can be a real prob-
lem, particularly when the nest is in an
old tree. Each year new material is
added and the nest gets bigger and
bigger until the sheer weight of it
breaks the limb and the nest comes
tumbling down. This isn't a problem if
it happens during the off season but
when it happens during nesting time,
The actual sighting of an osprey in
the early part of March tells us there
are other changes taking place in our
world. It tells us that the water has
warml�,d,up and that there is a new
awakening in the mud. The eels and
flounders that the osprey lives on dur-
ing these early months are vital for
their survival. Later, as the menhaden,
or bunkers, move in, along with the
weakfish, stripers and others, they will
become fair game. The bunker, in par-
ticular, is one of the favorite foods of
the osprey and the one most often
caught. Schools of these bunkers were
once common throughout our bays
and Sound but lately their numbers
have dwindled because of overfishing.
And now a new threat is taking its
toll. Some people feel this new threat
is depleting the bunker schools and
therefore making it difficult for the
ospreys to find enough food to feed
their young.
As I said earlier bunkers were the
mainstay of the osprey. Often, if you
look closely, you can see the shiny
menhaden in the claws of the osprey
as it flies by. When we spent summers
on the beach the osprey from the
nearby nest would often fly low
directly over us carrying these shining
fish. The predator that has moved in
to cut down the number of bunkers
available is the cormorant. This skillful
fisherman has literally increased by
the thousands in our local waters and
one of its prime foods
is the menhaden, par-
ticularly the young
menhaden.
Dr. Paul Spitzer,
who worked many
years ago with our
local ospreys, believes
cormorants might be
one of the reasons we
had such poor nesting
results in our osprey
population last year.
Could this lack of
menhaden be the
cause? At one time
this fish was so com-
mon that they were
caught in long nets
from shore by the mil-
lions and used as fer-
tilizer on our farms.
Needless to say, you
could tell when there
were good hauls
because there was an
odor in the air of rot-
ting fish. The Indians
had taught the white
under every hill of corn. Later fish
meal from fish such as the bunker was
made into fertilizer and even food
upplements for cattle and poultry.
e depletion of the bunkers shows
nce again man's greed. He literally
ished himself out of the menhaden
usiness and in so doing changed
nature's balance.
The increase in the cormorant pop-
ulation has become such a problem
that in places where commercial fish-
ing is taking place harsh steps are
being called for. The destruction of the
eggs at the nesting sites is being con-
sidered. Nature has become out of
balance and solutions are not that eas-
ily found.
I have worked with ospreys for the
past 40 or 50 years and have seen
many of their nests. Some, like on
Gardiners Island, are built right on
the sand because they have no land
predators. Through the years their
nests have piled up rubble three to six
feet in height. I've seen an osprey fly
toward a tree, grab onto a branch and
snap it off and carry it back to its
nest. When cornstalks were the thing
years ago I remember seeing an
osprey dive down to the ground and
pick up a cornstalk and fly back to its
All sorts of objects are used — old
shoes, rope, seaweed, plastics, almost
anything — and even the deadly
killer, monofilament fishing line,
finds its way into the nesting site.
I've rescued, with the help of my son,
two ospreys that were dangling
underneath their nests after they had
been entangled in monofilament fish
line. The fisherman who takes the
line off the reel and throws it over-
board is doing a grave injustice
somewhere down the line (no pun
intended). Monofilament never rots
or decays but lays a deadly trap for
fish, crabs, osprey and other birds.
Some will get entangled and starve
to a horrible death just because they
can't rid themselves of someone's
careless act.
The natural location for an osprey
nest is in a tree and when I was a kid
that was the only place you'd find
them. Later as I grew up I'd find they
nested directly on the beach at Gar -
diners Island but there they have had
problems with gulls. The herring gull
and the black- backed gull have be-
come so numerous on the island that
the osprey is continually being ha-
w== --- mw�
'assed by them. The gulls are so per-
sistent that the osprey spends much of
its time defending its nesting site
when it should be out fishing. A par-
tial solution was to move platforms
inland on the island to get the ospreys
away from the gulls. Once again we
see nature out of balance, perhaps
because man has provided so much
food for the gulls and made their pick-
ings so rewarding.
Robins Island, on the other hand,
still does not have gulls nesting on its
shores. It's the outer islands like Plum
and Gardiners that they nest on. The
ospreys on Robins Island still build
their nests in trees in the conventional
way. If you want to see ospreys in
their native habitat, which is rather
hard to find these days, Robins Island
is the place. Not that you can go on
the island, but you can sail around it
and see from the water the magnifi-
cent tree nests along its edge.
While we are on the topic of os-
preys, Barbara and I have spent a
good deal of time riding around to see
if we could find the first osprey to
arrive. One of the last places we vis-
ited was Orient Beach State Park and
what do you think we found? Atop
one of the platforms, a mere 300 feet
west of the buildings, out in the marsh
to the right, was a great horned owl
nesting on an osprey platform. We vis-
ited it twice and each time we could
plainly see the fluffy tufts of feathers
that look like ears on this magnificent
predator. So get in your car and take a
trip to the state park. It's always a