October 04, 2001 - Phragmites: friend and foeThe Suffolk Times • October 4, 2001
Phra
ites. 0
friend and foe
WE HAVEN'T HAD OUR CAMPER Out since I had
both my knees replaced but seeing I'm getting
around better now, Barbara and I thought it would
be fun to camp at Smith Point County Park on Fire
Island for a week. That name Fire Island brings
back such fond memories for both of us, since we
lived there summers when I worked for the
National Seashore.
We were soon on the expressway heading west to
William Floyd Parkway, where we swung south and
drove until we hit the county
Focus park with its huge parking
field and campground to the
ON east. We found a nice spot
NATURE overlooking the Great South
1Z
Bay where it narrows down to
by Paul Smith Point.
Stoutenburgh We had arrived late in the
afternoon and only had time
for a walk around the park, but the next morning
we were up early to check on any .birds that might
be migrating through. We saw strings of cormorant,
heading west. These slender - bodied, dark birds
with their long necks and slender, hooked bills
migrate in large V-shaped flocks like migrating
geese, but are silent when flying. The name cor-
morant means "sea crow."
Then we saw the strangest thing. Tree swallows
that normally use the barrier beach as their feeding
grounds as they move westward on their migration
were heading east. Evidently there were no flying
insects to the west so the word was put out, head
east. It actually put them in the opposite direction
of their usual migration. Most were tree swallows,
the ones with the white bellies.
Photo by Paul Stoutenburgh
One of the colorful shrubs of fall is the staghom
sumac with its colorful leaves and cone - shaped seed
head of crimson berries. It makes a good wild food
that can often last throughout the winter. Some peo-
ple make a tea out of Its berries.
It was nice to see the park had saved a natural
buffer of wild cherry, shad, bayberry, Virginia
creeper, sumac, rosa rugosa, high -tide bush and a
host of other plants between the campsites and the
water. This area was off limits and secured by a
four -foot chain -link fence. Along with the various
plants was that devilish invader, phragmites, the tall
reedlike plant that we find along most wet areas. In
the fall its big plume spreads its seeds via little air-
borne silken parachutes. This is one reason it has
spread so far and wide. These little floating seeds
drift everywhere. It's not unusual to see phragmites
growing away from the water, along our highways,
in fields of just anywhere there's enough moisture
for the seeds to germinate. Once germinated they
send out underground runners up to 50 feel long on
which grow a continuous line of new shoots.
It does have some good points, even though it's
invaded our salt- and freshwater marshes, and in
many places has replaced or almost replaced the
native plants that once grew there. Its rootstock is
about as dense a system as you can find, and
because of this and its invading qualities, phrag-
mites can act as a strong deterrent to erosion. In
many areas where erosion takes place you'll see
clusters of bare roots still holding on along the '
water's edge, even after all the sand and soil parti-
cles have washed away.
Phragmites also acts as a filtering agent. As a
matter of fact, it has been used in critical road
runoff areas, specifically to help absorb pollutants
and filter the murky water. We have two of these
manmade reed beds in our town, one on Skunk
Lane in Cutchogue, the other on Boisseau Avenue
in Southold. These reed beds are man's way of tak-
ing advantage of phragmites' good properties.
How to get rid of phragmites? That's a touchy
question because usually phragmites is near a
marsh area and these marsh areas come under the
jurisdiction of the New York State Department of
Environmental Conservation. So if you're thinking
of eliminating it, you should first get permission
from the DEC. Phragmites is a tough one to elimi-
nate, for no matter now well you work at it, as tim(
goes by, it will sneak back in and you'll find your-
self fighting the same battle over and over again.
And where did all this phragmites come from,
you ask. Most can't remember seeing it when they
were young. I myself can't remember seeing it whet
I was a teenager in any great quantities anywhere
in the Town of Southold, but that was a long time
ago. Has it just appeared in recent years? We did a
little checking and found that years ago Roy
Latham, the renowned naturalist of Orient, found
the first single small stand of this grass in Orient in
1900. He reported a second stand of a few plants in
Cutchogue in 1918 and by 1920 the species had
appeared in a number of places on the South Fork,
plus new localities on the North Fork. These were
all small, insignificant patches.
It has been suggested that there is a new strain of
phragmites that is more aggressive and persistent
than the earlier stands and this might account for
the seemingly rapid spread it has had in the past 20
to 30 years. This aggressiveness, coupled with man's
disturbance of the land through dredge spoil areas
and other activities along the waterfront, has given
phragmites the perfect opportunity to spread. As a
point of interest, phragmites is known throughout
the world in one form or another.
Let's get back to our
buffer zone along the Manmade reed
waterway at the camp-
ground at Smith Point. beds take
It was good to see the advantage of
park had wisely left this
belt of green. We saw phragmites'
many brown thrashers good properties.
and catbirds feeding on
the bumper crop of
berries this area had to offer. Like all migrating
birds, they were waiting for that northwest wind to
help them along on their migration route, but see-
ing there was no wind that day they were busy refu-
eling with berries and insects. It was good to see the
brown thrashers, for they seem to have left our
woods back home.
With my binoculars I could see red - breasted mer-
gansers. These diving ducks were feeding just off
shore. They had moved in from the north and will
probably be with us throughout the winter. These
mergansers have long, pointed bills armed with
rows of sharp, tooth -like projections that enable
them to hold onto the slippery killifish and others
that they live on.
So remember, if you want to enjoy a short fall
outing, head for the William Floyd Parkway. Go
south as far as you can and you're at Smith Point
County Park with Fire Island National Seashore
just to the west. Get out your hiking boots and see
this world- renowned barrier beach complex.
In these trying times, a little outdoors goes a long
way in bringing you back to reality. Take a little
time to get out, and your world might just become a
bit more stable. Just finding a little space for your-
self sometimes helps. In this time of confusion and
concern we soon learn there are others with greater
problems than our own.