March 28, 2002 - A goodbye to a fallen comradeThe Suffolk Times • March 28, 2002
goodbye
to a fallen comrade
Times /Review photo by Paul Stoutenburgh
This little goldfinch, dressed In its winter plumage, was feeding at one of our
thistle feeders when a hawk rushed in and scared all the birds away. Sorry
to say this unfortunate goldfinch flew up trying to escape, hit one of our win-
dows and was killed.
1 "D LIKE TO RELATE AN 1ncicent inat
happened on our back porch that
made us feel sorry and sad. Barbara
and I were eating breakfast as we
always do by the big window. It gives
us a good view of our woods and bird
feeders that hand
FOCUS from our back
porch. Just the
ON day before an
NATURE unfortunate
goldfinch had
by Paul flown into the
Stoutenburgh window and was
killed. What had
happened was one of the woodland
hawks that prey on small birds dashed
in and scared the feeding birds up,
some flying into the window trying to
When we heard the bird hit the win
dow we went out and picked it up. It
was dead. Barbara held it in her hands
as we looked at its beautiful winter
colors and dainty shape. We then tem-
porarily laid it down on a flower shelf
nearby with the idea of later burying
it.
Well, that was a day ago. Now, as we
munched on our morning toast,
Barbara happened to look out the win-
dow and there was another goldfinch
not six inches away, crouched down
just looking at its deceased comrade.
It made us think that maybe, just
maybe, the bird world does have feel-
ings somewhat like our own. For here,
this beautiful little finch that was once
alive, and now dead, had what
anneared to be a mourner by its side.
Was this one of the group that every
day visits our feeder and gives us such
pleasure? Were there real feelings
there? We'll never know. The bird
stayed frozen in place for probably 10
or 20 minutes. Then it was gone. It
made us think about things we had not
thought about before.
Goldfinches are one of the latest
birds to nest. They are just starting to
nest when most other birds have
fledged their young and the summer is
half over. It's believed the reason for
the goldfinch holding off its nesting
dates is that, being mostly a seed eater,
it waits until-plants have gone to seed.
This theory is backed up by close
observation of baby birds being fed a
regurgitated, half - digested mass of
seeds at each feeding. By late summer
the goldfinch's favorite food, the this-
tle, is now bursting through its pod,
along with a multitude of other seeds
that become available.
I remember finding my first
goldfinch nest in the abandoned park-
ing lot that was once an outdoor movi
theater just west of Moores Woods in
Greenport. It was truly a work of art.
Its outside structure was made of
woven grasses and what looked like
fine strips of bark. But the real wonder
was the interior of the nest. It was
made up of soft thistle and cattail
down, the perfect insulator. The nest
was but five feet off the
ground in an autumn
olive bush, which made
it easy to look into.
As I recall, it was the
beginning of
September, a late date
for any bird to be
thinking of nesting,
except the goldfinch.
The goldfinch's late nesting abit usu-
ally places it outside the devilish nest-
ing habit of the cowbird. Remember,
the cowbird is the culprit that lays its
egg in other birds' nests, leaving the
unexpected host the job of incubating
its young. This wouldn't be half bad if
that's all there was to the story, but it
isn 't. Usually the young cowbird hatch-1
es a few days before the other young
and therefore is fed first and gets a
head start before the host's young even
hatch out.
This habit of the cowbird laying its
single egg in other birds' nests is some-
times foiled by the host bird rebuilding
a completely new nest over tne cow-
bird's egg. This outsmarting by the h4
bird is only occasionally found, sorry
It's more likely the cowbird's fiendish
trick is successful, with the end result
being the young cowbird has grown
bigger and stronger, so much so that it
demands and gets most of the food
that's brought to the nest. It seems odd
that most parent birds don't realize
what's going on, but continue to feed
the young cowbird to the detriment of
its own young.
One last bit about
the young cowbird: It
grows so fast and so
big and is so greedy
that it often pushes the
smaller, weaker birds
right out of the nest.
Now it has no competi-
tion and so develops
into a strong, healthy cowbird that will
grow up to follow in its parents' foot-
steps.
This trick of a parent bird's shirking
its rearing duties, leading to the demise
of other young nestlings, has devastat-
ed some near - extinct species, such as
the Kirkland's warbler. So concerned
are some birders that they go out to
the warblers' nesting grounds and liter-
ally remove the cowbird's egg from the
warbler's nest, thereby assuring the
young warblers' rightful place in the
sun.
While we are on the subject of finch-
es, I'm sure many of you have noticed
colored bird that comes to your feeder
or that you see in your driveway or
yard. It has an interesting history, for
at one time there were none of these
birds found in the east, the reason
being it originally came from the west,
where it flourished from Alaska to
Mexico.
Because of its cheery song and strik-
ing color, it was often captured from
the wild for caged -bird sales in pet
shops in- the city. Then, when the pet-
shop owners were informed they had
illegal birds for sale and they became
aware of the legal ramifications, they
set their caged birds free. The year was
1940. Little did they realize how this
bird, a visitor from the west, would
soon start to spread throughout the
metropolitan area. Today, it's been
seen as far north as Maine and as far
south as Georgia. It's taken its place
along with the house sparrow in nest-
ing and food supplies. They both do
well around man. The finch often nests
in hanging flower pots, clinging ivy
vines, birdhouses and many of man's
other structures.
From that meager beginning back in
1940, they've become a common feed-
er bird, sometimes to the extent of
there being just too many. They are
cheerful little birds, the male with his
raspberry coloring and the female with
her streaked grayish -brown coloring.
We have both finches that come and
feed at our finch feeders. One is the
tube feeder, where only finches can
feed by hanging upside -down, which
keeps the other birds away. Then
there's the sock feeder, which is basical-
ly a coarsely woven net bag especially
made for finches, that we put thistle
feed in. They seem to like that even
better than the tube feeder. It makes it
easier for their little claws to grab the
mesh and hold on as they pull the
seeds out. Many seeds are dropped,
which makes it nice for the doves, spar-
rows and juncos that feed on the
ground exclusively. And so we have the
two finches that are colorful and cheer-
ful to have around, the goldfinch and
the house finch.
P.S. We've now moved our feeders a
good distance away from the house,
where the little goldfinch was killed.
Those woodland hawks are just getting
a little too aggressive, so we'll have to
do everything we can to make it safe
for our feeder friends.